Man with head down surrounded by pointing hands.

Exile

Throughout history, a popular method to minimize ‘troublemakers’ was to exile them to distant lands. It was believed that their absence would help maintain control over the situation. The plan never worked because in exile ‘troublemakers’ were considered heroes for the cause.

There are modern forms of exile that the world still invokes. Today we call it ‘cancel culture’ and it happens when one voice dares to speak against power. No, I’m not going to discuss transgenderism, socialism or any current political trend. Today, I’m thinking about faith.

The current so-called ‘convert surge’ has created tension within the Church, I’m not sure we expected. We all say we want people to ‘come to Orthodoxy’ but when that means challenging our ‘version’ of faith, maybe we’re not so sure anymore.

Inquirers often arrive in the Narthex after reading a few books, watching a few viral Orthodox videos, and skimming a few blogs. They are already convinced the Church is true, and they aren’t wrong. The Church IS true. The problem isn’t the truth. The problem is the people.

When we view the Church only from the point of view of theology and the Holy Canons, it is easy to forget there are real people inside the building. These real people are all struggling to live up to the standards of faith in a ‘not-so-supportive’ society.

In other words, when we walk outside the walls of the Church building, we are all faced with opposition at varying levels. Some opposition is cultural. Some opposition is relationship oriented. Some opposition (I believe the hardest) is in our own hearts.

Today, the Church commemorates Saint Paul the Confessor, Patriarch of Constantinople. He was exiled several times for his Orthodox faith. As the Church learned to navigate the relationship with supposed Christian emperor, oftentimes people and faith came into conflict.

Church history isn’t always clean and tidy. Some issues like understanding the Holy Trinity required generations to resolve. Some Christians are still struggling to resolve the mystery of the Trinity in their hearts and faith. Only looking back can we see the truth shine.

That brings my mind back to the current ‘convert surge’. Many inquirers enter the Narthex and immediately judge those already present as lazy and wrong. Those on the inside aren’t fasting properly. They aren’t praying properly. They aren’t defending the faith properly.

Many accuse the clergy of being heretics and ‘sell outs’ to culture. Some go so far as proclaim judgment on entire synods, suggesting bishops should be deposed. And this comes from those who ‘just yesterday’ were sitting in Protestant Churches clapping to praise bands.

I get the feeling many of today’s inquirers would be first in line holding torches and pitchforks, demanding exile, only to realize when the dust settled, THEY were the wrong all along. Living Orthodoxy isn’t ever easy. It never has been, but we can learn from the past.

Before we light the torches, let’s consider where WE might be wrong. Before we put our ‘name in the hat’ for sainthood, we should take a step back and think. One thing is for sure. We are all this together, good and bad, sinners and saints, cradle and convert.

Orthodox Christianity hasn’t always ‘looked’ like it does today, and it won’t always look like it does today. The future will bring its own challenges to the Church just as the past did. The Church will change as it always has, not in truth, but in practice. We don’t need to exile anyone.


2 Comments

  1. David Hensley on November 7, 2026 at 8:55 pm

    Father,

    I read your November 6 article, Exile, with considerable interest. As someone who has spent decades studying Scripture, theology, and the history of Christianity, I appreciate your concern regarding spiritual pride, judgment, and division within the Orthodox Church. These are legitimate concerns that deserve serious attention.

    However, I found a troubling irony in your article. While cautioning converts against judging others, you appear to engage in some of the very generalizations and dismissive attitudes you are warning against.

    You write:

    “And this comes from those who ‘just yesterday’ were sitting in Protestant Churches clapping to praise bands.”

    What theological purpose does this observation serve? Does having worshipped in a Protestant church somehow diminish one’s intellectual credibility, spiritual maturity, or ability to recognize theological error?

    Surely, a person’s previous denominational affiliation does not determine the validity of his arguments. The truth or falsity of a theological claim must be established through Scripture, history, and sound reasoning, not through dismissive references to where someone previously worshipped.

    Indeed, the implication seems especially unfortunate coming from a tradition that places such considerable emphasis upon humility.

    You rightly criticize converts who presume to judge clergy, bishops, and lifelong Orthodox Christians without sufficient knowledge or understanding. Yet your characterization risks making a similar mistake in reverse: judging the spiritual maturity and theological competence of converts based upon their Protestant backgrounds.

    Is this not precisely the sort of judgment your article seeks to discourage?

    There is also a distinction that deserves greater consideration: the difference between spiritual arrogance and theological discernment.

    Not everyone entering an Orthodox church arrives with knowledge acquired from a handful of YouTube videos or internet articles. Some have spent decades studying the biblical languages, early Church Fathers, ecumenical councils, historical theology, and the development of Christian doctrine.

    Some have devoted their lives to ministry, biblical scholarship, and the serious pursuit of Christian truth.

    When such individuals ask difficult questions concerning apostolic succession, ecclesiastical authority, Holy Tradition, or the relationship between Scripture and the Church, their questions should not automatically be interpreted as evidence of Protestant arrogance.

    They may instead represent precisely what the Apostle Paul commended among the Bereans.

    Acts 17:11 states:

    “These were more noble than those in Thessalonica, in that they received the word with all readiness of mind, and searched the scriptures daily, whether those things were so.”

    These believers examined even the apostolic proclamation against the Scriptures. Their diligence was praised rather than condemned.

    If examining the teachings of an apostle was considered noble, surely sincere examination of the teachings of a priest, bishop, or ecclesiastical tradition should not automatically be considered presumptuous.

    This does not mean that every criticism is justified, nor does it excuse disrespect toward clergy. It simply means that questioning a theological claim and attacking the person making that claim are two fundamentally different things.

    I was also struck by your assertion that the Orthodox Church is true and that the problem lies with people rather than truth itself.

    I understand this conviction within Orthodox ecclesiology. Nevertheless, for those investigating Orthodoxy, the claim that the Orthodox Church uniquely preserves the fullness of apostolic Christianity is precisely the proposition under examination.

    One cannot reasonably expect an inquirer to accept that conclusion before examining the historical and theological evidence supporting it.

    To do so risks circular reasoning: the Church is true because the Church declares itself true, and its declarations are authoritative because the Church is true.

    A church confident in its apostolic foundations should welcome serious historical examination rather than regard thoughtful scrutiny as an unwelcome challenge.

    Furthermore, Church history itself provides numerous examples of theological disagreements involving bishops, clergy, monks, and laypeople. The controversies surrounding Arianism, Nestorianism, and iconoclasm demonstrate that ecclesiastical office alone has never guaranteed theological correctness.

    Indeed, Orthodox history honors individuals who defended what they understood to be apostolic truth even when influential ecclesiastical authorities opposed them.

    Of course, this does not mean that every modern critic is another Athanasius or Maximus the Confessor. Such comparisons would be presumptuous. It does, however, establish an important principle: respect for ecclesiastical authority must not be confused with the assumption that every exercise of that authority is beyond legitimate examination.

    Your observation that Orthodox Christianity has changed in practice throughout history is particularly important. I appreciate your willingness to acknowledge that distinction between enduring doctrine and developing practice.

    Yet that acknowledgment also raises a legitimate historical question: How do we determine which practices faithfully preserve apostolic Christianity and which reflect later cultural or ecclesiastical developments?

    Surely, answering that question requires careful investigation rather than merely appealing to the fact that a practice currently exists within Orthodoxy.

    Finally, I would respectfully suggest that the language we use concerning Christians from other traditions matters.

    Many Protestants sincerely love Jesus Christ, revere the Holy Scriptures, confess the Holy Trinity, and devote their lives to serving God and their neighbors. Whatever theological disagreements exist between Protestantism and Orthodoxy, those disagreements should not obscure the sincerity of their Christian devotion.

    If we desire Protestants to investigate Orthodoxy seriously, we should avoid language that makes their previous Christian lives appear spiritually or intellectually inferior.

    Your article concludes with an appeal for unity, humility, and an acknowledgment that cradle Orthodox Christians and converts are struggling together.

    That is a worthy conclusion, and one with which I wholeheartedly agree.

    But perhaps the principle should be extended further.

    If converts should approach lifelong Orthodox Christians with humility, should not lifelong Orthodox Christians and their clergy approach converts with that same humility?

    If converts should refrain from making assumptions about the spiritual condition of others, should not clergy likewise refrain from making assumptions about the knowledge, motives, and spiritual maturity of those arriving from Protestant traditions?

    And if we are truly concerned about preventing unnecessary exile, perhaps we should ensure that sincere theological inquiry does not become grounds for making thoughtful seekers feel unwelcome.

    Humility cannot be demanded exclusively from those entering the Church. It must also be demonstrated by those welcoming them.

    I offer these observations not in hostility toward Orthodoxy, but out of respect for the serious theological questions involved and the importance of pursuing Christian truth with intellectual honesty, charity, and humility.

    Respectfully,

    David J. Hensley
    M.A., History
    Biblical Scholar and Christian Author

    • Be Transfigured Ministries on November 9, 2026 at 9:25 am

      Thank you for your comments. I will admit my comment was a bit snarky but I do it make a point. The emphasis of the post isn’t about honest theological discussion. It is about coming from the outside and telling those on the inside they are ‘doing it’ wrong. My comment about Protestant worship isn’t a judgment about Protestant worship. It is a reminder that ‘they’ do what ‘they’ do and ‘we’ do what ‘we’ do. I won’t show up in another church and tell them they are ‘doing’ it wrong. I expect the same courtesy in return. As you know me personally, I always welcome honest conversation and dialogue.

Leave a Comment





Recent Comments